One-on-One
Why social media rewards negative content
Clip: Season 2026 Episode 2972 | 9m 2sVideo has Closed Captions
Why social media rewards negative content
Bond Benton, PhD, Professor of Strategic Communication at Montclair State University, sits down with Steve Adubato to examine how social media algorithms reward negative content, the potential consequences for developing brains, and strategies to address these concerns.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
One-on-One is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS
One-on-One
Why social media rewards negative content
Clip: Season 2026 Episode 2972 | 9m 2sVideo has Closed Captions
Bond Benton, PhD, Professor of Strategic Communication at Montclair State University, sits down with Steve Adubato to examine how social media algorithms reward negative content, the potential consequences for developing brains, and strategies to address these concerns.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch One-on-One
One-on-One is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship(upbeat music) - We continue our series, "Media Matters" with a scholar over at Montclair State University, Dr.
Bond Benton, who's Professor of Strategic Communication at Montclair State University's College of Communication and Media.
Bond, good to see you.
- Good to see you.
- Talk to us about your specialty in social media, Why you're interested in social media, and what should be our greatest concern right now?
- I am in public relations, and one of the things that I studied a little over a decade ago was just how powerful social media was, particularly in getting a brand's message out, but what I kind of discovered, most unfortunately, was that the same infrastructure that gets a brand's message out can get terrible information out, and that infrastructure that rewards terrible information is something that we, as concerned citizens, parents, educators, and members of the community, really, really have to be aware of.
- Professor, you've said that social media is not a neutral space.
What do you mean by that?
- Social media rewards bad content.
There is an algorithm that is competing for people's attention.
What consistently gets people's attention more is terrible things.
So you're gonna see awful content in social media.
They're gonna amplify it, because that's the sort of thing that will get the clicks, right?
If you see something adorable and charming, you'll kind of smile and move on, but if you see something that offends you, you're gonna click on it and get engaged.
They recognize that, and they really monetize the use of terrible content to make people stay on platforms.
- Let me push back a little bit in this way.
- Sure.
- It's not even pushing back.
It's trying to understand this.
I have an ongoing discussion with our team about how we use social media, and it's like, "Steve, we need more social media engagement.
We need more digital engagement."
All that's true, because underwriters and sponsors want to see what's your digital engagement, and I often wonder a conversation like this, Professor Benton, conversation like this, policy-oriented, somewhat intellectual, hopefully, accessible and relatable to folks, not gonna kill it on the clicks, is it?
- No, it's not, and that is... You know, I think that there's the old quote that was attributed to Mark Twain that, you know, the truth will, by the time truth gets its pants on, you know, the lie has ran halfway across the world, and, yeah, it's not that... There's a kind of take-your-medicine quality to it as well.
I had thought, previously among young people, some of the criticisms of social media sounded like some of the antique criticism of like rock and roll and comic books, you know, "Oh, the media that the kids are on, it's really, really bad."
It's just sort of maybe we cried wolf too many times as researchers.
Social media is, objectively, like it has pretty harmful effects, unlike other kind of like moral panics about previous youth-oriented media.
- This is different.
- Yeah.
- That's what you're saying.
- Yeah.
- You're saying when Elvis Presley came out.
- Exactly.
- And the networks would not show him below his waist, because it was somehow scandalous or The Beatles, the whole bit, well, rock and roll, it was gonna destroy our kids' mind, whatever.
You're saying social media is different.
- Yeah, social media is distinct.
I think that there was a lot of, you know, sort of overstated things, yeah, like heavy metal's gonna make kids deliver worshipers.
They shouldn't play Dungeons and Dragons.
All of this was really baseless moral panics, but with social media, we're getting an inkling of some of the data around it, and, objectively, it's a problem.
One of the studies that I did was on the Buffalo mass shooter, Payton Gendron, and the manifesto that he released prior to the mass shooting.
We did, with a co-author, a forensic analysis of that manifesto, and what we discovered was that there was a very predictable pattern to his internet engagement that took him from kind of sketchy places online to, objectively, evil places online in pretty short order, and, you know, that's just one study we did.
There's documentation that, you know, women engaging with Instagram and with a lot of frequency, they're gonna be more likely to have disordered eating because of that.
There is like quality data out there that shows social media has pretty harmful effects when consumed in an unhealthy fashion.
- Devil's advocate, can't stop it.
- No.
- Can't stop it.
Someone says, "Yeah, well, the professor's concerned.
He's done this research, it's dangerous, but everyone has a right to use social media as they choose to."
How the heck are we gonna regulate it differently, manage it differently?
What advice do we have for parents?
It is what it is, isn't it?
Or am I missing something?
- No, absolutely, you're not missing anything, and there is no regulatory framework that's gonna be successful.
A researcher that I've worked with pretty extensively has studied something called the Digital Services Act in the European Union, which sought to regulate some of the structures of social media.
You know, I think it's well intentioned.
It hasn't really done anything.
- Enforceable?
- What's that?
- Enforceable?
- Not enforceable, and it shouldn't be in some ways, and it is going to really come down to a lot of things.
I think that consumer advocacy is going to be a big part of it, that we are going to have to, as consumers, start to make some choices that if we see a platform that just is continually giving us content, that we can see that it's not making our lives better, maybe making us scared, maybe, you know, giving us problematic information, then we're gonna have to maybe say that, "Enough with that platform," and that's gonna be part of it.
Parents' education will be another big part of it as well.
You know, I don't know about the specifics of the legality, but the recent judgment against Meta related to youth harms and social media, it's not sort of dissimilar to early, the lawsuits against the tobacco industry that, you know, we started with cigarettes are cool, and James Bond smokes them, but, you know, over time, people started to say, "Maybe there's a pretty negative consequence to this."
If we're maybe kind of getting an awareness of that, that the hope for self-regulation, I think is gonna only come when the market demands it, and we're part of the market.
- But, Bond, if (sighs) it's playing with our minds, if the algorithm knows how to mess with us, and not me, it's just anyone.
- Yeah.
- But there are certain things I'm drawn to, but if someone's mind is caught up in cat videos, dog videos, little baby videos, which harmless, right?
It plays with our mind.
I guess it's called dopamine.
I don't totally understand it.
What do you mean self-regulate ourselves if something's happening to the chemicals in our brain?
- As far as what you've just described, I wouldn't have any problem with that.
- That's not the problem.
- Oh, no, no, no.
- That's not the problem.
- And I follow a certain sports team that I think most people in your viewership would despise this sports team, but you know, I'll watch- - Who is it?
The Chiefs.
I'm from Kansas City originally.
- All right, we can end the interview right now.
- Okay, I figured as much.
- I'm Patrick Mahomes fan.
Go ahead, I'm sorry.
- Oh, yeah.
I would totally get with that, but, you know, I'll read, you know, fake injury reports all the time, and, you know, I know that the infrastructure that gives me those fake injury reports are the same ones that give anti-vaccination information, too, right?
Like we he need to click more.
- That's dangerous.
- Right, yeah, exactly, and I think that, you know, the ability to make that distinction between sort of harmless clicking on content to relieve boredom, I mean, it's not a lot worse than watching, you know, like the least objectionable television show in the 1970s and '80s, and everybody did that for years.
So I mean, I don't think that there's anything, you know, problematic about that, but there is some legitimate content out there that really makes people more vulnerable, and it could be dangerous.
- Dr.
Bond Benton, who's Professor of Strategic Communication at our higher ed partners at Montclair State University's College of Communication Media.
Hey, Bond, thank you so much for joining us.
- Thank you so much.
- We appreciate it.
- For having me, and thank you for bringing this issue up.
It's just essential we talk about it.
That's got to be the important first step, and thank you so much for taking that step.
- Will not be the last conversation.
I'm Steve Adubato, that is Professor Benton.
We'll see you next time.
- [Narrator] One-On-One with Steve Adubato is a production of the Caucus Educational Corporation.
Funding has been provided by EJI, Excellence in Medicine.
A New Jersey health foundation program.
The Adubato Center for Media Leadership.
Valley Bank.
Newark Board of Education.
New Jersey Board of Public Utilities.
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
The North Ward Center.
PSEG Foundation.
And by New Jersey Sharing Network.
Promotional support provided by Meadowlands Chamber.
And by Insider NJ.
- Are you looking to be a part of a dynamic, forward-thinking business service organization?
At Meadowlands Chamber, every day we connect, collaborate and innovate, helping to drive business and economic growth in the greater Meadowlands and New Jersey.
I invite you to visit our Meadowlands Chamber headquarters, an open office facility with access to resources for our members' businesses and networking needs.
Together, we will build the chamber of the future, and the next generation of leaders.
Back to One — Return to Ground Zero: Loss and healing
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 Ep2972 | 7m 18s | Back to One — Return to Ground Zero: Loss and healing (7m 18s)
Cancer survivor & doctor discuss her transformative journey
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2026 Ep2972 | 10m 55s | Cancer survivor & doctor discuss her transformative journey (10m 55s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.


New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
One-on-One is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS


